I'm no motor head but our boats are pretty heavy for their size and that model isn't built with the fast tab hull so I'm sure there is some lost speed there as well.
What type of boat was this 26 footer? That makes a huge difference. Look at Ken Cipra's Sunsation. It's almost 29 feet long and weighs in at 4,650 pounds. That's almost 6 feet longer than your boat and less than 1,000 pounds heavier. So if it was a lighter model like a Baja, Sunsation, Nordic, etc that would definately make a difference.
Also, if he had more deadrise he'd probably be cutting through the chop a little better than your 18 degrees gives you. There are just alot of different factors besides engine size that would affect the speed.
Duo-Prop is great for handling but put your boat next to an exact duplicate with a Bravo 1 and it will outrun you.
As far as tabs go, they won't help much for gaining any speed but do help in leveling things out in the chop. I boat in Tampa Bay and I use my tabs all the time to get the back up out of the water with the trim and then put the nose down a bit more with the tabs.